Bjoern Daehlie (NOR) is generally considered one of the greatest male skiers in history (or even the greatest). Â He raced during much of the 90’s until his career was cut short by a rollerskiing accident in which he injured his back. Â One of his biggest competitors during this time was Vladimir Smirnov (SOV, KAZ). Â Which one was really faster?
Let’s look at races where these two great skiers competed against each other directly. Â I found 87 races where they both participated[1. I’m sure there are some more; in particular, I’m not catching the very early end of their careers, pre-1991.]. Â If we look at a graph of the difference in FIS points in each race, we get the following:
The vertical scale can be a little mind bending here, since we’re looking at the difference in FIS points, and lower FIS points are better. Â That means a positive value (> 0) means that Daehlie won and vice versa.
Daehlie mostly had the upper hand in 1991-1992, but Smirnov improved for the next 2-3 seasons, making the two skiers considerably more evenly matched. Â Several interesting aspects to this data:
– Head to head, Daehlie seemed better at skating, while Smirnov was a stronger classic skier.
– The 1993-1994 season was the best for Smirnov, as this is the only season I see where he actually beat Daehlie more often than he lost.
– If you’ll notice, the Daehlie victories (above the line) seem slightly more spread out, vertically, than the Smirnov victories (below the line). Â We might conclude that when Smirnov lost to Daehlie, we was somewhat more likely to lose by a large margin.
– One exception to this is the obvious outlier in 1995, in which Smirnov crushed Daehlie. Â That was a 50k classic in Oslo in which Smirnov won (the whole race) and Daehlie was 48th, more than 10 minutes out. Â I think it’s fair to say that Daehlie had a rough day on the trails that time.
– Â And of course, we need to observe the general trend here: Daehlie was stronger in the early 90’s, they were reasonably evenly matched for 1-2 seasons, and then Daehlie started to pull away again.
[ad#AdSenseBanner]
{ 4 } Trackbacks
[…] metric to use? Â The most unequivocal measure is simply their head to head results. Â That’s easy enough to do if you only want to compare two skiers at a time, but what if we wanted to think […]
[…] week I posted a short item looking at how Bjoern Daehlie and Vladimir Smirnov fared against each other, head to head. […]
[…] Finally, you get to choose which pair of skiers I analyze next (see the poll on the right) as in Daehlie vs. Smirnov. Â It’s a tight race so far… var a2a_config = a2a_config || {}; […]
[…] – I tackled the timeless question: Daehlie vs. Smirnov. […]
Post a Comment